Best All-Weather Car Mats: Keep That Interior Showroom Fresh

Our top choices cover the entire area and protect against wear. They also protect the footwells from grime and debris.

byNoelle Talmon| UPDATED May 18, 2022 7:27 AM

The Drive and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links. Read more.

Best All-Weather Car Mats: Keep That Interior Showroom Fresh

Our Methodology

Keeping my cars clean is a priority, and I understand the importance of investing in high-quality products that perform as promised. I took many factors into consideration when selecting the best all-weather car mats. I made sure to choose items from well-known brands, such as WeatherTech and Husky Liners, which have a reputation for producing top-notch floor mats and liners. I selected mats that are specifically designed to tolerate winter conditions with the ability to trap snow, slush, and mud, which can stain carpets and vehicle interiors if not contained properly. Since I couldn’t review all of the mats on this list, I consulted consumer feedback to see how they performed in real-world conditions. I also chose mats in a wide range of prices to suit a variety of budgets. For more information on our methodology, go here

Why Trust Us

Our reviews are driven by a combination of hands-on testing, expert input, “wisdom of the crowd” assessments from actual buyers, and our own expertise. We always aim to offer genuine, accurate guides to help you find the best picks.

Learn more

Best All-Weather Car Mats Reviews & Recommendations

Specs

  • Brand: WeatherTech
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: Thermoplastic elastomer (TPE) compound

Pros

  • Heavy duty and durable
  • Easy to clean
  • Won’t curl up, crack, or harden
  • No harmful PVCs

Cons

  • Don’t work in all vehicles
  • Rear mats may be a little small

The WeatherTech Universal Trim-to-Fit All-Weather Floor Mats are our top overall pick because they are durable, relatively easy to clean, look good, and are backed by a reputable brand in the car care industry. These mats prevent the carpet in your vehicle from getting wet and dirty. They feature reservoirs and tall outer edges to keep water, salt, and slush from penetrating. They are heavy duty and are designed to be cut so you can customize them to fit your particular make and model vehicle.

We recommend measuring your car or truck’s existing mats in advance and compare them to the measurements of the WeatherTech mats to ensure a proper fit. The mats stay solidly in place due to their heavy weight and their patented grip, which stops them from shifting. They have left- and right-side designs and are designed to withstand sub-zero weather conditions, so they don’t crack, curl up, or harden. Constructed of rubber-like TPE compound, they are free from damaging PVCs.

Specs

  • Brand: Armor All
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: Rubber polymer

Pros

  • No odor
  • Easy to clean
  • Inexpensive
  • Won’t crack, curl, or harden

Cons

  • Back mats are small
  • Back mats don’t feature anti-slip claws

If you're looking for a budget-friendly option, the Armor All Four-Piece Black Rubber All-Season Trim-to-Fit Floor Mats work well in cars, trucks, and SUVs. While they are inexpensive, they are not cheaply made. They're thick, long-lasting, and feature anti-slip cleats that keep them securely in place so they don't move around. These all-weather mats are designed to trap mud, salt, snow, and water and can tolerate sub-zero temperatures up to 100 degrees or so without cracking, curling up, or hardening.

To install them, simply trim them to fit with a pair of scissors. Just make sure to check the dimensions to ensure that they will work in your particular vehicle. One downside is that the back mats are a little small for some vehicles, and they don't feature the anti-slip claws, so they may move around a bit.

Specs

  • Brand: Husky Liners
  • Fit: Various trucks; search for your particular make and model
  • Material: Thermoplastic olefin (TPO)

Pros

  • Easy to install
  • Easy to clean
  • Won’t shift
  • Snug fit

Cons

  • May leave some gaps in coverage
  • Slippery when wet

The Husky Liners Weatherbeater Series includes front- and rear-seat floor liners. The series is designed to fit a variety of truck make and models, so make sure you search for your exact vehicle. This particular set is designed for 2015-2022 Ford F-150 SuperCrew Cabs. They are easy to install and clean and feature cleats so they don't shift around. The mats feature grooves to catch water, mud, or sand and prevent it from spilling onto the carpet.

While these mats are designed for specific vehicles, you still may need to trim them slightly for a perfect fit or if you notice gaps in some sections. In general, they fit snugly against every curve of the front seats, and the large rear floor liner covers the entire floor and even reaches under the back seat. One downside is that they can get slippery when wet.

Specs

  • Brand: Zone Tech
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: PVC Rubber with NBR and natural rubber material

Pros

  • Trim to fit
  • Easy to clean
  • Good coverage

Cons

  • Emits a slight odor
  • Not very heavy duty

The heavy and durable Zone Tech All-Weather Rubber Semi-Pattern Car Interior Floor Mats are a great option for trucks and SUVs but can also be used in passenger cars. The best part of this set is the mat for the cargo area or trunk. It can be used in a variety of different makes and models, such as a Dodge Nitro, Toyota 4Runner, Honda HR-V, and Mitsubishi Outlander.

This trim-to-fit set is made of soft rubber that is easy to cut with scissors, so you can customize it to suit your particular needs. The mats feature channels that contain water and slush so fluids don't spill over onto the carpet, and they also trap dirt and mud. The mats are easy to clean with soap and water. However, these mats emit a slight odor and aren't as heavy duty as some competing brands.

Specs

  • Brand: FH Group
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: Rubber

Pros

  • Multiple colors available
  • Easy to trim
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • May emit an odor
  • Not as heavy duty as some other options

The all-weather FH Group Trimmable Rubber Floor Mats come in a variety of colors, including black/red, black/beige and black/blue. They are large enough to fit a truck or SUV, or you can cut them to fit a smaller sedan. While these mats are not as heavy duty as some other brands, they're medium weight and substantial enough to stay firmly in place due to their nibbed backing.

They feature tall outer edges, and they're waterproof and stain resistant. They are designed to catch snow, mud, rain, dirt, and other debris. The mats are easy to clean with a garden hose, however, they may not provide total coverage. Also, the back mats might slide around a little.

Specs

  • Brand: Caterpillar
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: Rubber

Pros

  • Odorless
  • Easy to trim
  • Easy to clean
  • Durable

Cons

  • Back mats a little large for some vehicles
  • Not very heavy duty

The Caterpillar ToughRide Heavy-Duty Four-Piece Rubber Floor Mats are easy to trim and modify to fit a variety of vehicles, from trucks such as Dodge Ram to cars such as Toyota Prius to SUVs such as Ford Escape. Simply cut along the lines with a pair of scissors for a customizable fit. These durable weatherproof mats collect debris, including water, snow, and slush, to protect the floor of your vehicle.

They feature linear and diagonal ridges to trap and contain dirt and dust. They also have rubberized nibs on the bottom so they stay firmly in place and grooves on the top for traction. Simply shake them or wipe them down to clean them off. Unlike other brands that emit an odor for a short time, these mats do not have an offensive smell. However, the back mats may be too large for some vehicles even if you trim them. Also, they're not as heavy duty as some rival brands.

Specs

  • Brand: Genuine Dickies
  • Fit: Universal
  • Material: Rubber polymer

Pros

  • Anti-skid design
  • Thick, durable construction
  • Deep channels collect dirt and debris
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Rubber smell
  • Require cutting

The Genuine Dickies Heavy-Duty No-Trim All-Weather Floor Mats are versatile and designed to fit trucks, SUVs, minivans and cars. They feature rubber construction that is thick enough so they don't move around under your feet. The tread pattern and anti-skid design keeps them from slipping, and they remain flexible even in cold temperatures.

These mats have deep channels that collect rain, mud, dirt, gravel, and snow and have a reinforced heel pad so they last longer. The mats are easy to clean with soap and water and/or a hose. One downside is that you must cut them apart out of the package. Also, they can emit a slight rubber smell for a short time.

Our Verdict 

The name WeatherTech is synonymous with all-weather floor mats. This company has a reputation for producing some of the best floor mats available. The WeatherTech Universal Trim to Fit All Weather Floor Mats are a great option. For a more budget-friendly option, consider the Armor All Rubber All-Season Trim-to-Fit Floor Mats

What to Consider When Buying All-Weather Car Mats

There are basically two types of all-weather car mats: universal fit mats and those designed for specific vehicles. When shopping for floor mats, fit is essential. You don’t want mats that are too small or too large because they might not provide enough coverage or they’ll interfere with the pedals. They can also move around, which can be a hassle. It’s also important to check whether the mats emit an odor because that can be unpleasant if you’re stuck in the vehicle with the stinky mats.

Key Features

Size/Fit

Floor mats come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and materials, and while some are classified as a universal fit, there really isn’t a one-size-fits-all option. The best all-weather car mats are either vehicle specific or you can trim them with scissors to fit your vehicle. It's important to measure your current mats. Do your homework and see how easy or difficult it is to trim the mats and how much coverage they actually provide for the front and rear areas of your vehicle. 

Odorless

Since all-weather car mats are typically made of rubber or a similar material, they may emit an unpleasant rubber-like odor. Some of these mats simply need to be aired out for a couple of days after you open them from the package, but others may retain that smell for a longer period of time. The best brands have little to no scent at all. 

Pricing 

All-weather floor mats are available in a variety of prices. Some options cost less than $25, making them quite affordable. Mats in this range are typically a universal fit and might require trimming for the best fit. These mats are generally not as heavy duty as more expensive options. If you spend a little more, you can find other types of universal-fit mats that are a little more rugged and durable. They tend to be thicker and longer lasting. The most expensive mats can cost $100 or more, and they are designed to fit specific vehicles. While costly, they provide the best fit and are contoured to fit your interior floor nearly perfectly. As a result, they provide the best protection against rain, snow, slush, mud, and other elements.

FAQs 

You’ve got questions. The Drive has answers.

Q: What's the difference between floor mats and floor liners?

A: Liners are molded to the floor space, so they fit tightly against the footwells and cargo area of specific vehicle makes and models. Floor mats are flat bottomed and are often a universal fit for various makes and models. 

Q: Are rubber floor mats worth it?

A: Compared to carpeted mats, rubber mats are better at containing dirt, grime, and moisture. They are also durable and easy to clean.

Q: What are all-weather floor mats?

A: All-weather car mats are designed to protect your vehicle's interior from a variety of different elements, including rain, mud, and snow. They usually have grooves that catch debris and prevent it from spreading to other areas of your vehicle.

stripe
stripe