Mazda Has Reportedly Stopped Benchmarking BMW

While it may sound bad for the Bavarians, Mazda says things aren't that simple.

Bloomberg via Getty Images

Mazda is largely known for making attainable, well-made cars that also happen to be a riot to drive. To create such deliciously handling vehicles, the company has been known to use BMWs as benchmark products. However, according to a report published by AutoGuide, those days are over. 

You see, when BMW says that it builds the "Ultimate Driving Machine," it's a claim that historically, for the most part, was true...until it wasn't. Outside of its top-shelf M cars, most modern mainstream Bimmers lack the tactile engagement and driving joy that characterized their forebearers. Mazda knows this and has therefore moved on from the Bavarians when choosing a yardstick with which to compare its own vehicles, according to a Mazda engineer who spoke to AutoGuide.

In lieu of BMW, the engineer says Mazda now benchmarks an automaker that seemingly couldn't be more different: Toyota. He specifically lauds the new, much-sportier-than-before Camry, expressing concern that "if the Camry sold so well before when it was so boring to drive, they now actually have a good handling car on their hands."

It's all a little hard to believe, isn't it? We thought so too and therefore reached out to Mazda for further explanation. On a call with The Drive, Mazda spokesperson Jacob Brown was able to provide a little more context. While AutoGuide's report may, on the surface, look bad for BMW and great for Toyota, Brown stresses that behind-the-scenes, things ain't so simple. 

The spokesperson didn't refute his colleague's statements, but did clarify that Mazda's approach to benchmarking isn't as straightforward as one might think.

"Mazda doesn't straight up say, 'Okay, for the new Mazda 3 we're going to benchmark the Civic, Corolla, Sentra, and Elantra' or something like that," said Brown. "What the engineers do is benchmark unique qualities. So if the Chevy Cruze is the quietest car in the class, we're going to benchmark NVH against the Cruze, we're going to benchmark handling and ride quality against the Civic, and so on. We benchmark specific qualities against each car."

In regards to the company engineer's claims that the Toyota Camry has booted BMW from its position as Mazda's driving dynamics benchmark, Brown says, "The new Camry is very good, I don’t think that anybody’s gonna deny that. And frankly, with a few exceptions, BMW’s dynamic qualities have catered more toward a comfort audience rather than a sport audience."

Toyota

Move over, BMW?

"You kind of have to look at what they’re doing as a company," said the Mazda rep. "BMW’s going for a broader audience to grow market share and that means that they may not be making cars as aggressive as they were. Whereas the Camry is certainly going for a sportier feel."

While a little ridiculous to hear at first, it's hard to argue against. As BMWs become more comfort-oriented and Toyotas grow to be more fun, I personally look forward to the day one can unequivocally say that an upmarket Camry is a better driver's car than a 328i

As for the wide variety of cars Mazda has used as reference points, Brown says the Mazda R&D parking lot has played host to everything from Porsches, BMWs (obviously), to Cadillacs, and even Aston Martins. "It isn’t necessarily about benchmarking car-for-car, class-for-class," said Brown. "It means that we are gonna take the best attributes of whatever vehicle that may be."