Reviews

LAST UPDATED:  February 16, 2021

The Best Winter Coats (Review & Buying Guide) in 2021

Stay toasty in your winter coat in the coldest of winter temperatures.

Entering our 7th season of /DRIVE on NBC Sports, and with millions of YouTube and Facebook followers, The Drive is a leading authority of all things automotive.

The Drive on NBC The Drive on YouTube The Drive on Facebook

The Review Team

The Drive and its partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links. Read more.

PUBLISHED ON February 16, 2021

The leaves have changed, and the temperatures are dropping. You’ve layered on the sweaters, but now you need to head outside. A durable and protective winter coat is just what you need. The right winter coat will be comfortable to wear, keep you warm, protect you from precipitation, and look great.

 

However, not just any coat will do. Finding the perfect winter coat is about picking one with the right amount of insulation and is durable to last through several winters. Your coat needs to be the right style and design to withstand the type of activity you plan to do while wearing it, whether that’s heading outdoors for adventure, motorcycle riding, or heading to work. Don’t struggle and shiver your way through the next winter season. Buy the perfect winter coat, and feel warm and comfy.

Best Overall
Carhartt Men's Quilted Flannel Lined Duck Active Jacket
LEARN MORE
Summary
Summary

This durable winter work coat is made of tough 100 percent cotton with a nylon lining. It comes in six colors. 

Pros
Pros
  • Comes with large front pockets and quilted flannel lining
  • Machine washable
Cons
Cons
  • Oversized sizing
  • Material is stiff
Best Overall
Carhartt Men's Quilted Flannel Lined Duck Active Jacket
Best Value
Gemyse Women's Mountain Waterproof Ski Snow Jacket
LEARN MORE
Summary
Summary

This women’s winter coat comes in 12 colors. It has a durable waterproof outer shell and soft fleece lining. 

Pros
Pros
  • Has a waterproof level of 10000mm
  • Features heat retention technology
Cons
Cons
  • Sizing not accurate
  • Construction not durable
Best Value
Gemyse Women's Mountain Waterproof Ski Snow Jacket
Honorable Mention
 Levi's Men's Type III Sherpa Jacket
LEARN MORE
Summary
Summary

This sporty jacket comes in 16 denim color options with a soft Sherpa lining. There are three design options, regular, tall, and big. It has the classic red type styling with welt pockets and button closure.

Pros
Pros
  • Machine washable
  • Comfortable and flexible fit
Cons
Cons
  • Sizing runs small
  • Denim colors can be slightly off
Honorable Mention
 Levi's Men's Type III Sherpa Jacket
The Best Winter Coat
Amazon

Why Trust Us


All of our reviews are based on market research, expert input, or practical experience with most products we include. This way, we offer genuine, accurate guides to help you find the best picks.

Learn more

Benefits of Winter Coat

  • Stay warm. The most significant advantage of a winter coat is that it will keep you warm. They have additional insulation that helps to retain your natural body heat while also blocking the cold. 
  • Express your style. Winter coats come in various colors and designs. This lets you choose the color and cut that will compliment your personal style. You could even have more than one coat, one for sporty activities and one for more formal or professional activities. 
  • Avoid sickness. Staying warm and dry means you’ll avoid getting sick. Protective clothing like a winter coat helps you to avoid the winter flu and sniffles that seem to be all too common. 

Types of Winter Coats

Peacoats

This classic winter coat design got its start with sailors. It’s typically made from heavy fabrics like wool. They have a shorter cut and a slight flare at the bottom to give you a broader range of motion. They also have larger lapels that you can flip up and have increased protection during bad weather. 

Trench Coats

This type of winter jacket is protective with a longer cut that can protect a large portion of your legs. While they can have some insulation, they tend to have less than other options on this list. You’ll find many options that have a waterproofing treatment to make them useful during inclement weather. 

Down

You may have heard these jackets referred to as puffer jackets. This is due to the puffed-up look they have from the down or other insulation used in them. Look for a jacket that has a quilted or channeling pattern stitched into it. This will help to keep the insulation in place and prevent clumping. You’ll find that these jackets tend to be the warmest, and you’ll want to find one rated for the temperatures you plan to be in. 

Top Brands

Carhartt

Founded in 1889 in Dearborn, Mich., with two sewing machines, the Carhartt brand has grown to be one of the most trusted in making durable denim and duck material products. You’ll find their clothing ideal for tough and industrial settings. The Carhartt Men's Big & Tall Arctic Quilt Lined Duck Traditional Coat is perfect for wearing when working outside. 

The North Face

Founded in 1966 in San Francisco, Calif., The North Face brand is a leader in the outdoor sporting goods and clothing industry. Its product line is extensive and covers a broad range of outdoor activities. The North Face Women's Gotham Jacket II is both stylish and effective at keeping you warm. 

Marmot

Founded in 1974 in Grand Junction, Colo., this outdoor sporting goods company focuses on sustainability and technology. While it may not be in every retail store, its products are high-quality and dependable. The Marmot Men's Tullus Hoody Winter Puffer Jacket gives you that classic winter coat look. 

Columbia Sportswear

Founded in 1938, the Columbia name is known worldwide as a leader in outdoor sporting goods equipment and clothing. Its product line features both familiar and innovative options for every outdoor enthusiast.  For the ultimate in warmth, the Columbia Women's Heavenly Hooded Jacket is sure to please. 

Winter Coat Pricing

  • Under $50: You can find a quality winter coat in this price range. They tend to be simpler designs and have fewer features. They may have less insulation and not be rated for extremely cold temperatures. Synthetic insulation is most common in this range. 
  • $50 to $100: The majority of quality winter coats fall into this category. They come in a variety of styles with several features. They’ll also have either down or synthetic insulation. 
  • $100 and up: These are top quality winter coats with the highest quality down insulation, several innovative features, and lots of adjustability for versatile use. 

Key Features

Insulation 

There are two basic types of insulation to choose from: down and synthetic. Down is a natural material. It’s the undercoat of ducks and geese. It’s highly effective at keeping you warm, incredibly light, and can last a long time. Synthetic insulation is water-resistant, easy to care for, and more affordable than down. Some jackets take this a step further with heating elements built inside of the jacket

Outer Shell 

The shell is the outer layer of the jacket. This material takes the brunt of the winter weather, so it needs to be durable and protective. It also needs to be attractive. While the outer shell of your jacket can be a wide variety of materials, you’ll want to pay attention to if it's water-resistant or waterproof. Resistant will keep out light water for a short period. Waterproof will perform better at keeping out moisture. 

Inner Lining 

This is the inside layer of the jacket that’s going against your skin. It should be soft to the touch to be comfortable. It also needs to be effective at retaining heat. Flannel is an effective layer at keeping you warm. You’ll also want a material that can wick moisture away from your skin. This will help keep you drier and, thus, warmer. 

Other Considerations

  • Pockets. You need a jacket that has plenty of pockets for carrying all of your belongings. It should have pockets for your hands on the outside. Then there should be pockets on the inside that are more protective for your electronics, wallet, or other valuables. Some also are more secure with zippers or Velcro. 
  • Hood. A jacket with a hood will offer you more protection and help keep you warmer. Look for a jacket that has a removable hood. That way, you can use it when you need it and remove it when you don’t. This lets you wear the jacket for longer during the winter season. 
  • Adjustability. Some jackets will come with adjustable features. This lets you fit the jacket to your body. A close and secure fit is ideal because this is what helps to keep you warm. There should be adjustable features at the neck, cuffs, and bottom of the jacket. This seals out the cold. 

Best Winter Coat Reviews & Recommendations 2021

Best Overall
This jacket for men has the classic Carhartt look for which the brand is famous. It’s made of 100 percent cotton and manufactured in the U.S. There are a quilted nylon lining and a front zipper closure. No dry cleaners are necessary for this jacket as it is machine washable. For those cold rainy days, there’s a hood with a drawstring to keep you covered. This coat helps protect you from those frigid winter winds with the rib-knit cuffs at the wrist and waistband. This jacket is not meant to fit snugly on your torso, it’s great for layering, and you should expect that it’s bulky. While at first, the jacket will feel stiff, it will soften over time.
Best Overall
Carhartt Men's Quilted Flannel Lined Duck Active Jacket
This jacket for men has the classic Carhartt look for which the brand is famous. It’s made of 100 percent cotton and manufactured in the U.S. There are a quilted nylon lining and a front zipper closure. No dry cleaners are necessary for this jacket as it is machine washable. For those cold rainy days, there’s a hood with a drawstring to keep you covered. This coat helps protect you from those frigid winter winds with the rib-knit cuffs at the wrist and waistband. This jacket is not meant to fit snugly on your torso, it’s great for layering, and you should expect that it’s bulky. While at first, the jacket will feel stiff, it will soften over time.
Best Value

The shell is water repellent with reinforced, waterproof zippers, and pockets to protect you while you’re playing in the snow or running errands on a rainy day. The lining is made of a soft, breathable fleece that will keep you warm and cozy without getting overheated. There’s adjustable Velcro around the wrists and a drawstring for the detachable hood to prevent wind from penetrating the jacket. No need to carry a bag for your essentials, as this jacket has a large mesh pocket for your phone, wallet, and other accessories. One neat feature about this jacket is there is an earphone fastener inside the jacket to help keep your earphones in place even while you’re on the go. 


This jacket tends to lack durability, so it may not be the best choice for rugged activities. However, it’s perfect for casual activities and running errands. You may find the sizing to be slightly off.

Best Value
Gemyse Women's Mountain Waterproof Ski Snow Jacket

The shell is water repellent with reinforced, waterproof zippers, and pockets to protect you while you’re playing in the snow or running errands on a rainy day. The lining is made of a soft, breathable fleece that will keep you warm and cozy without getting overheated. There’s adjustable Velcro around the wrists and a drawstring for the detachable hood to prevent wind from penetrating the jacket. No need to carry a bag for your essentials, as this jacket has a large mesh pocket for your phone, wallet, and other accessories. One neat feature about this jacket is there is an earphone fastener inside the jacket to help keep your earphones in place even while you’re on the go. 


This jacket tends to lack durability, so it may not be the best choice for rugged activities. However, it’s perfect for casual activities and running errands. You may find the sizing to be slightly off.

Best Style

This jacket is suited for guys who are looking for a stylish look for more mild winters. These Sherpa jackets look great with chinos or cords and leather boots. This jacket lends a quality of rugged outdoorsmanship without having to chop any wood. It is made of machine-washable cotton and comes with a snap button closure and welt pockets. The pockets are not lined with Sherpa, so why not pick up a pair of wool gloves while you’re at it to complete the look?


 You may find that the jacket sizing runs small. However, you can account for this by ordering your jacket in a bigger size. You may also find the color to be slightly off.

Best Style
Levi's Men's Type III Sherpa Jacket

This jacket is suited for guys who are looking for a stylish look for more mild winters. These Sherpa jackets look great with chinos or cords and leather boots. This jacket lends a quality of rugged outdoorsmanship without having to chop any wood. It is made of machine-washable cotton and comes with a snap button closure and welt pockets. The pockets are not lined with Sherpa, so why not pick up a pair of wool gloves while you’re at it to complete the look?


 You may find that the jacket sizing runs small. However, you can account for this by ordering your jacket in a bigger size. You may also find the color to be slightly off.

Best Down Jacket
This classic puffer jacket is made of 100 percent nylon with 100 percent down feather filling. It will provide warmth on some of the coldest days and is machine washable to keep it looking and smelling fresh. For the brand conscious, the brand is displayed on the chest without pulling attention away from the quilted details. This jacket will keep you warm on chilly mornings and will surely snare a few compliments. This jacket is available in both regular and big and tall sizes, but size up if you like to wear thick sweaters underneath.
Best Down Jacket
Tommy Hilfiger Men's Packable Down Jacket
This classic puffer jacket is made of 100 percent nylon with 100 percent down feather filling. It will provide warmth on some of the coldest days and is machine washable to keep it looking and smelling fresh. For the brand conscious, the brand is displayed on the chest without pulling attention away from the quilted details. This jacket will keep you warm on chilly mornings and will surely snare a few compliments. This jacket is available in both regular and big and tall sizes, but size up if you like to wear thick sweaters underneath.
Most Durable
It has a quilted nylon exterior with a poly-blend lining. This jacket has ribbed knit material around the collar, reminiscent of the popular bomber jacket look. The waist is not cinched in the front, so it’s not a true bomber jacket. It just resembles one. Without the ribbed knit material at the front, the jacket appears very fresh and stylish. No need to worry, though, because there is ribbed knit material around the cuffs and along the back waist, which will help prevent drafts. The pockets are designed to keep your hands warm. The jacket is water-resistant and is designed for more of a snug fit while remaining comfortable when you need to move around. 
Most Durable
Dickies Men's Water-Resistant Diamond Quilted Nylon Jacket
It has a quilted nylon exterior with a poly-blend lining. This jacket has ribbed knit material around the collar, reminiscent of the popular bomber jacket look. The waist is not cinched in the front, so it’s not a true bomber jacket. It just resembles one. Without the ribbed knit material at the front, the jacket appears very fresh and stylish. No need to worry, though, because there is ribbed knit material around the cuffs and along the back waist, which will help prevent drafts. The pockets are designed to keep your hands warm. The jacket is water-resistant and is designed for more of a snug fit while remaining comfortable when you need to move around. 
Honorable Mention

This insulated work jacket is made from 65 percent polyester and 35 percent cotton. The outside shell is an eight-ounce vet dyed twill. The lining is four-ounce nylon. The insulation in the jacket is polyurethane foam. It comes in eight colors for you to choose from. The styling of the jacket is rugged with durable construction. The material is both water repellent and resistant. You can adjust the fit of the jacket at the waist with built-in tabs. The zipper is a heavy-duty brass to give you reliable performance. There are two slit pockets on the front, a pencil pocket on one sleeve, and a hidden internal pocket. 


The downside of this jacket is that the material can be stiff, which makes the jacket feel bulky. However, with wear, you’ll break the jacket in, and it’ll be more comfortable.

Honorable Mention
Dickies Men's Insulated Eisenhower Front-Zip Jacket

This insulated work jacket is made from 65 percent polyester and 35 percent cotton. The outside shell is an eight-ounce vet dyed twill. The lining is four-ounce nylon. The insulation in the jacket is polyurethane foam. It comes in eight colors for you to choose from. The styling of the jacket is rugged with durable construction. The material is both water repellent and resistant. You can adjust the fit of the jacket at the waist with built-in tabs. The zipper is a heavy-duty brass to give you reliable performance. There are two slit pockets on the front, a pencil pocket on one sleeve, and a hidden internal pocket. 


The downside of this jacket is that the material can be stiff, which makes the jacket feel bulky. However, with wear, you’ll break the jacket in, and it’ll be more comfortable.

Honorable Mention

Stay warm in this 100 percent polyester winter coat. To keep you warm, the jacket has a synthetic down lining. The outer shell is 100 percent polyester, while the lining is 100 percent nylon 210T taffeta. The shell has Columbia’s water-resistant Storm-Lite DP II to keep you warm and dry. The construction of the jacket features a classic fit and comes in 13 colors. There are two zippered hand pockets and an internal security pocket. It also has a hood with removable faux fur trim. 


One drawback of this jacket is that the hood isn’t removable. But if you’re looking to stay as warm as possible, this isn’t a big deal. The sizing also runs big, but you can account for this by sizing down when you order. 

Honorable Mention
Columbia Women's Peak to Park Insulated Jacket

Stay warm in this 100 percent polyester winter coat. To keep you warm, the jacket has a synthetic down lining. The outer shell is 100 percent polyester, while the lining is 100 percent nylon 210T taffeta. The shell has Columbia’s water-resistant Storm-Lite DP II to keep you warm and dry. The construction of the jacket features a classic fit and comes in 13 colors. There are two zippered hand pockets and an internal security pocket. It also has a hood with removable faux fur trim. 


One drawback of this jacket is that the hood isn’t removable. But if you’re looking to stay as warm as possible, this isn’t a big deal. The sizing also runs big, but you can account for this by sizing down when you order. 

Honorable Mention

This long length parka comes in four colors, black, green, grey, and blue. The outer shell is made of durable nylon that is both waterproof and breathable. It can outlast the winter and protect you from rain, sleet, snow, and hail. To keep you warm, 650 Premium down is quilted into the body of the jacket. The hood is detachable and has removable fur trim. You’ll find the jacket’s cut to be a classic fit that’s not too tight or relaxed to make it compatible with wearing over layers. 


One downside is that the coat is quite long, and the zipper experiences extra stress during movement, which can cause it to fail at the bottom. However, if you buy the coat at the right length, it shouldn’t be too long, and this isn't shouldn’t be an issue. 

Honorable Mention
Eddie Bauer Men's Superior Down Parka

This long length parka comes in four colors, black, green, grey, and blue. The outer shell is made of durable nylon that is both waterproof and breathable. It can outlast the winter and protect you from rain, sleet, snow, and hail. To keep you warm, 650 Premium down is quilted into the body of the jacket. The hood is detachable and has removable fur trim. You’ll find the jacket’s cut to be a classic fit that’s not too tight or relaxed to make it compatible with wearing over layers. 


One downside is that the coat is quite long, and the zipper experiences extra stress during movement, which can cause it to fail at the bottom. However, if you buy the coat at the right length, it shouldn’t be too long, and this isn't shouldn’t be an issue. 

Honorable Mention

If you need a jacket that people will see you in, then this one in high visibility yellow is perfect. It’s made from 100 percent polyester that’s 250 denier and has a water-repellent finish. To help your jacket stay bright, it has a stain-release treatment. All of the seams are fully taped to help the jacket be waterproof. Inside the jacket is a brushed polyester quilt lining for comfort. The jacket is rated ANSI Class 3 for insulation and warmth and Level 2 for visibility. There are 3M Scotch reflective tape accents through the jacket. 


One downside of this jacket is that it isn’t waterproof. You’ll be fine in light snow and rain, but anything heavier will cause the jacket to leak. While the jacket has a stain blocker, it doesn’t completely prevent it from getting dirty and dingy. 

Honorable Mention
Carhartt Men's High Visibility Waterproof Class Three Insulated Sherwood Jacket

If you need a jacket that people will see you in, then this one in high visibility yellow is perfect. It’s made from 100 percent polyester that’s 250 denier and has a water-repellent finish. To help your jacket stay bright, it has a stain-release treatment. All of the seams are fully taped to help the jacket be waterproof. Inside the jacket is a brushed polyester quilt lining for comfort. The jacket is rated ANSI Class 3 for insulation and warmth and Level 2 for visibility. There are 3M Scotch reflective tape accents through the jacket. 


One downside of this jacket is that it isn’t waterproof. You’ll be fine in light snow and rain, but anything heavier will cause the jacket to leak. While the jacket has a stain blocker, it doesn’t completely prevent it from getting dirty and dingy. 

Honorable Mention

If you’re looking for a winter coat with unique style and flair, then this jacket and its 40 color options are perfect. The jacket is constructed from 100 percent nylon and is safe for the washing machine. Insulating the jacket is an ultra loft polyfill for a midweight jacket. There are comfort features like rib-knit storm cuffs and a fleece-lined collar. There’s a single front zipper with two external hand pockets. An internal zippered storage pocket gives you secure storage of your valuables. 


One drawback of this jacket is that it tends to run small, but you can easily order a size up and get a coat that fits. The outer shell layer is thin. However, this isn’t the insulation layer and does not affect the warmth of the coat. 

Honorable Mention
Tommy Hilfiger Men's Classic Hooded Puffer Jacket

If you’re looking for a winter coat with unique style and flair, then this jacket and its 40 color options are perfect. The jacket is constructed from 100 percent nylon and is safe for the washing machine. Insulating the jacket is an ultra loft polyfill for a midweight jacket. There are comfort features like rib-knit storm cuffs and a fleece-lined collar. There’s a single front zipper with two external hand pockets. An internal zippered storage pocket gives you secure storage of your valuables. 


One drawback of this jacket is that it tends to run small, but you can easily order a size up and get a coat that fits. The outer shell layer is thin. However, this isn’t the insulation layer and does not affect the warmth of the coat. 

Tips

  • Try on your jacket before you need to wear it. This lets you confirm that it fits over your winter clothing and is comfortable for you to wear. 
  • Look for a jacket that’s designed to work in the temperatures you’ll be in. The higher the insulation rating, the colder the temperatures you can wear the jacket in. 
  • You may need more than one winter coat. A peacoat or trench can work best when dressing professionally or formally. A down puffer jacket is a more casual look. A parker will keep you the warmest when out in the wilderness. 

FAQs

Q: What is the warmest winter coat?

The warmest winter coats have flannel or similar fabric linings and quilted down insulation. Then the outer shell is weather and waterproof to keep out the precipitation and help you stay dry. They also have comfort features that allow you to adjust the jacket to seal out the cold air and prevent drafts. 

Q: What is the best winter coat brand?

The best brands are the ones that make winter weather clothing and gear, such as Marmot, The North Face, and Columbia. However, you can find several quality winter coats that are from lesser-known brands. 

Q: What should I look for in a winter coat?

Look for a jacket that you want to wear, fits you comfortably, and can keep you warm in the winter temperatures that you’ll experience. 

Q: How much should I spend on a winter coat?

Buy the best quality jacket that your budget can afford. Generally, the more expensive the jacket is, the better quality the materials and construction are. Invest in a coat that will last you several seasons so that you don’t have to buy a new jacket each year. 

Final Thoughts

The Carhartt Men's Quilted Flannel Lined Duck Active Jacket is an ideal winter coat with its durability and effective insulation. For a more affordable option, the Gemyse Women's Mountain Waterproof Ski Snow Jacket is both warm and stylish.