Best Aftermarket Headlights: Enhance Your Night Vision with Quality Headlights

Replacing worn-out headlights means safer driving. We’ve got options for making your next car ride brighter.

byChris Teague| UPDATED Dec 22, 2021 12:23 PM
Best Aftermarket Headlights: Enhance Your Night Vision with Quality Headlights
Share

Your headlights are one of the most important features of your car, allowing you to see after dark and allowing other people to see you. Even the best headlights wear out over time, however, and can become dim or burn out completely. While you may need to take your car to the shop for an oil change or tire rotation, changing out your headlight bulbs is something you can do at home. Check your vehicle’s service manual to make sure you know the right bulb type and size, and you can find anything you need online. There are dozens of LED alternatives—or even real LEDs if you’re willing to pay for them—but be advised that it’s illegal to add them to your car unless it came with them from the factory. I went in search of the best replacement bulbs for a variety of applications. Let’s get to it.

Our Methodology 

Why Trust Us

Our reviews are driven by a combination of hands-on testing, expert input, “wisdom of the crowd” assessments from actual buyers, and our own expertise. We always aim to offer genuine, accurate guides to help you find the best picks.

Learn more

I looked at more than two dozen headlights to find the best value pair, the best performing pair, and a few honorable mentions that are worthy of your consideration. Specifically, I looked at brightness, beam pattern, lifespan, and ease of installation, with cost factoring heavily into our consideration. We also avoided products with subpar bulb lifespan, overly cool color temperature, or overly warm color temperature in the name of performance. Further explanation of the process can be found here.

Best Aftermarket Headlights Reviews & Recommendations

Sylvania says its SilverStar headlights are whiter than traditional bulbs and provide better down-road visibility. The bulbs are sold in pairs and are available for a variety of vehicles, including off-road SUVs, trucks, and performance cars. The white hue of the lights makes an excellent upgrade for an older vehicle with yellowing lights, but you’ll still need to mind the headlight lenses to make sure you’re getting the best out of your new headlights.


The SilverStar bulbs are far from the most expensive you can buy, making them a great choice for people on a budget. Some buyers report that the bulbs are not as bright and don’t last as long as others on the market, but the value proposition here is strong enough to make Sylvania SilverStars a compelling option.


Product Specs

  • 910 lumens of brightness
  • 4,100K cool white color temperature 
  • Plug and play

Pros

  • Great value
  • Striking white light 
  • Easy installation

Cons

  • Not as bright as others
  • Doesn’t last as long as others

The XtraVision halogen headlight is a very bright light that would make a great replacement for your OEM headlamps. These bulbs offer enhanced down-road visibility while working to eliminate glare for an improved safety and driving experience. Remember: Visibility is one of the most powerful passive safety features a vehicle can have.


Besides being economical, these lights offer an aesthetically pleasing light and are likely to be quite reliable; halogen lighting is a robust technology that’s been around for a long time. They are also DOT-approved, which means they are street legal. They illuminate long distances and can perform well in foggy conditions.


There are some downsides to running conventional halogen light bulbs, however. If you’re accustomed to LED lighting, these may not feel bright enough. Halogen bulbs also have a more limited lifespan compared to LED lights, so if replacing your headlights more frequently is a major consideration, your best bet is to look at other products.


Product Specs

  • Factory performance and brightness
  • 1700 lumens
  • Street legal

Pros

  • Factory light output or better
  • Designed for stock headlights with an ideal beam pattern
  • Inexpensive

Cons

  • Lower lifespan compared to LEDs
  • Less perceived brightness than LEDs
  • Looks more old school

The Torchbeam D3S HID bulbs are a great replacement for your xenon headlights and provide excellent nighttime visibility. Light quality is cleaner, brighter, and whiter than traditional headlights, and although this won’t just bolt into a car with non-Xenon lights, they make a great replacement option for those that do.


Torchbeam touts its headlights’ durability by noting that they are tested in extreme conditions and that they are constructed to withstand moisture, snow, ice, and vibrations. Various sizes and applications are available, so there’s likely a fit for your vehicle, and many users report great durability and lifespan from the bulbs.


Product Specs

  • Xenon replacement
  • 6,000K cool white color temperature
  • Five years

Pros

  • Durable design
  • Bright white beam
  • Longer projected light beam

Cons

  • Can be difficult to install
  • Customer service lacking
  • Some dead bulbs out of the box
Best Plug-and-Play Replacement
PIAA Xtreme White Hybrid Bulb

PIAA Xtreme White bulbs deliver great down-road illumination and a bright white color. Best of all, they are designed to be direct plug-and-play replacements for your car’s stock headlights, meaning you can buy them with no worries about installation. PIAA says the bulbs’ design and light beam projects light farther down the road and are able to brightly illuminate road signs and obstacles, such as animals and pedestrians.


The Xtreme White Hybrid bulbs are available for a wide variety of vehicles, so you’ll likely find a set for your application. PIAA sells them in pairs and recommends that both be changed at the same time. Keep in mind that if your car uses different bulbs for low and high beams, you’ll need to buy two sets of bulbs.


Product Specs

  • Bright white beam
  • 3,700-3,900K color
  • One-year warranty

Pros

  • Bright, focused white beam
  • Easy to install
  • Fits for cars of all types

Cons

  • Don’t last as long as expected
  • Some report yellowed light color
  • More expensive than many

Sometimes replacement headlight bulbs can be too bright or may be too intense. That’s where bulbs like Sylvania’s halogen replacements come into play. They offer a noticeable improvement over stock headlights without being overpowering or blinding others on the road. Sylvania’s bulbs are also affordable and won’t break your budget.


The High Performance Halogen bulbs are designed to work as both low- and high-beam headlights, so you can replace your aging factory lights with a single set and be done with the job. Sylvania makes the bulbs in a wide range of sizes and types, making it possible to find the right bulb for almost any car. 


Product Specs

  • Bright white beam
  • 4000-K color
  • One-year warranty

Pros

  • Bright white beam
  • Not overpoweringly bright
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Don’t last as long as expected
  • Bulbs may be too dim

Our Verdict on Aftermarket Headlights

We chose the Torchbeam LED Headlight Bulb Kit as the best overall aftermarket headlights. They’re a great plug-and-play option to improve visibility. Those on a budget should check out the Sylvania XtraVision High-Performance Halogen Headlight Bulbs, which are a reliable, no-fuss option.

What to Consider When Buying Aftermarket Headlights

Headlights are one of the most commonly modified and most important parts of a car that allow it to be a 24-hour all-weather machine that you can depend on. There are a few headlights you can consider with three major types: halogen, HID, and LED. All have different strengths and weaknesses when it comes to brightness, beam pattern, lifespan, and cost. While the options can be complicated, the end goal is simple: you’re looking for a bright bulb that works well with your vehicle’s lighting system.

Types of Aftermarket Headlights

Halogen Headlights

Halogen headlights are simple, old technology that uses electric current flowing through a thin filament encased in glass with an inert gas that allows it to shine brightly. That same filament is how halogen lights wear out and eventually break. With good light output and low cost, halogen headlights come standard in most carsand can vary in quality, longevity, and brightness.

HID Headlights

HID means high-intensity discharge. They are the brightest headlights you can buy but require extra parts that the LED and halogen lights don’t require. A large, dedicated aftermarket for HIDs exists with specialist websites specifically created to sell HID systems so you can customize them more than any other light style. Their excellent brightness is offset by a high cost of entry, easily double that of LED bulbs, along with the need for a ballast and ignitor module that the other lights don’t need because of the high energy demands of an HID. They also are not recommended to replace halogen bulbs because of their intense glare on the road.

LED Headlights

LED means light emitting diode, which is a semiconductor that emits light. Think of a laser or a computer chip specifically designed to shine brightly. LEDs require miniscule amounts of energy to run compared to halogens and HIDs and have the longest life of the three bulbs. Their only disadvantage is that the light source itself is a small chip compared to the entire bulb of the halogen or HID light, which can cause strange issues that can affect the beam pattern. Be aware that adding LED lights to a car not already equipped with them is against the law. Do not purchase LED conversions for your vehicle if it did not come that way from the factory.

Key Features

Service Life

Consider inquiring about a headlight’s service life before purchasing it. Lights with a longer service life last much longer without requiring repairs and replacements. Such headlights save you money because you do not need to purchase new headlights so frequently. You will also have some peace of mind when you don’t have to worry about your lights going off unexpectedly.

All three kinds of headlight bulbs have vastly different lifespans that are almost directly related to their cost. Halogens are extremely cheap to replace and have the shortest life, LEDs are moderately costly and have an extremely long life, and HIDs are the most expensive and boast a similarly long life with greater brightness. Headlights only wear with use, so consider how often you use them and determine if the extra cost of the upgraded LED or HID bulbs is worthwhile.

Wattage

Voltage and wattage affect the quality of light that your headlights will offer you. A higher voltage enables your headlight to provide you with more stable lighting. A headlight with a higher wattage gives you a brighter illumination for a better driving experience. The right headlight is one that gives you the amount and quality of light that you require while consuming less power.

Generally speaking, wattage determines how bright headlight bulbs will be.

For halogen and LED bulbs, this isn’t something that is a huge consideration because wattage is related to the style of bulb socket that car makers design their headlights around. With HIDs, there are two major choices: 35 and 55 watt. The 35-watt option is what most car makers use in their systems, while 55 watt is an aftermarket upgrade that increases light output substantially at the cost of bulb life.

Heat Production

This is a consideration when upgrading your headlights from the stock halogens. LED and HID headlights emit considerable amounts of heat when lit, and this can present issues if there isn't room behind the bulb for LEDs or if the headlight housing itself cannot handle the heat of an HID bulb. Most LEDs have a heat sink or fan at the back of the bulb that keeps things cool, so this isn’t a worry in most applications.

Energy Consumption

The amount of energy that a headlight consumes should be considered before purchasing a headlight. A headlight with a high energy consumption derives a lot of energy from the car’s battery. When such a headlight is left running for a long time, it may drain your battery. LEDs consume the least amount of energy, while halogens consume the most. HIDs are power hungry when they first fire, but then settle into a lower energy consumption than halogen.

Aftermarket Headlights Benefits

As your car ages, its headlights can dim or burn out completely. Beyond the obvious problem of being cited for driving without a headlight, there are serious safety issues that arise from missing lighting elements. Properly working headlights light up the road at night, but they also help other drivers see you. This is especially important during inclement weather such as fog and heavy rain.

Aftermarket headlights should also be on your radar if you plan on doing any sort of performance or off-road driving. Stock lighting may not be bright enough or have the right beam shape for what you’re trying to do. It’s important that you choose the right bulb for the job and that you pay attention to state and local laws when shopping. Some bulbs are illegal or not recommended for use on the road.

Aftermarket Headlight Pricing 

As with anything in life, you get what you pay for with headlights. The good news is that most bulbs are fairly reasonably priced. Expect to pay anywhere from a few dollars for a set of basic halogen bulbs up to over $100 or more for bright Xenon-style or HID headlights. Pricing also depends on your vehicle, as some require purchasing an entire headlight housing along with the actual lighting unit, which costs more. If your car came with LED or similar lighting systems, you may be looking at a trip to a dealer or shop and you’ll likely see a bill for several hundred dollars.

Tips and Tricks

As with anything you do for decades, you pick up a few tips and tricks along the way in terms of selecting the right product, and using it. That’s the case with us and aftermarket headlights. To help you bridge the information gap, here’s a selection of what we’ve learned along the way.

  • Make sure the headlights you buy are compatible with your vehicle. Although some headlights are universal, it is important to check your manufacturer’s manual just to be sure you are buying the right fit.
  • When aligning your headlights, make sure they are pointing slightly downwards to prevent blinding other motorists. As a courtesy, always dim your headlights when approaching other drivers.
  • Since laws regarding headlights vary from state to state, ensure the headlamps you buy comply with the regulations in your area to avoid trouble with the authorities.

FAQs 

You’ve got questions. The Drive has answers.

Q: Are aftermarket headlights legal for the road?

A: The aftermarket offers many options that include DOT-approved bulbs and non-DOT bulbs, which are recommended for non-headlight use like fog lights or turn signals. Make sure to look at your local laws for guidance if a non-DOT bulb is legal for your local roads.

Q: Can I install aftermarket headlights on my own?

A: Yes, it is possible to install headlights at home if you are armed with some simple tools. However, there are some headlamps that are difficult to install. In such cases, you need to consult a professional.

Q: Is brighter always better?

A: Not necessarily. It’s important to consider the kind of headlights your car has and what kind of bulbs they were designed for before you purchase bulbs. Often, the halogen works best with the best beam pattern even if it is dimmer than an LED.